-
27
Jan
Team Building
Free Online Articles Directory
Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
ABAnswers
0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Login
Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out
Email
Password
Remember me?
Lost Password?
Home Page > Business > Organizational > Team Building
Team Building
Posted: Nov 08, 2006 |Comments: 0
| Views: 900 |
]]>
BUILDING SUPERVISOR TEAMS:
A CASE STUDY
BACKGROUND TO THE PROJECT
In June 1999, I was contracted to lead a twenty-four hour team-building intervention with a group of twenty Managers, Supervisors, Lead personnel, and journeyman production employees of a major truck body manufacturer. This privately held company was founded in 1971 and is guided by its President and a General Manager who began as a shop floor laborer, and worked his way up the organizational ladder to his present position. Operating in three shifts, the 200-person company has 150,000 square feet of manufacturing, warehouse and office space in Southern California, and is the largest service body company in the western United States. Its clients include Ford and Chevrolet. My involvement was requested because of the need to design and deliver training in both Spanish and English. Audience characteristics are discussed in more detail, below.
This effort was a partnership between the California Manufacturing Technology Center (C.M.T.C.), based in Hawthorne, California, the Center for Economic Development at West Los Angeles College, and the Employment Training Panel, State of California, which funded the project. This author and C.M.T.C. identified the client’s main needs to be:
-Significant growth in production capacity and financial performance, especially during the last 2-3 years. This rapid growth has given rise to thousands of hours of overtime to meet customer demand; an increased accident rate; difficulty in recruiting skilled workers, particularly in the Fabrication Department; a “firefighting” approach to problem-solving and decision-making by management, which is mirrored throughout the organization; and unexpected stresses on equipment, machinery, and work processes. These stresses, in turn, have generated production bottlenecks and contributed to the “management by crisis” atmosphere of the plant.
-A stable workforce (see Table 1, below) who were reluctant, according to C.M.T.C., to adopt the new technology and work processes required by Lean Manufacturing. For example, a manufacturer’s representative who regularly services the plant as an account, reported that “veteran” workers resist learning new requirements, processes and materials, because of they feel their present their present technology and methods for painting truck bodies technology and processes they know well are adequate.
-A lack of reliable means to measure the actual amounts of scrap and re-work produced.
-Unpredictability of job scheduling associated with changing customer requirements and sporadic Company use of reliable scheduling tools.
-Re-occurring production bottlenecks on the shop floor, particularly with regard to the line producing their standard (vs. custom) products.
-Organizational “firewalls” between certain units and departments (e.g., Standard vs. Cargo vs. Sport production lines) that result in production and organizational inefficiencies. For example, the customized jigs and fixtures designed and built by a company Engineer for the particular requirements of one production line, could be effectively adapted for use on other production lines. However, production inefficiencies resulted from employee resistance to adapt or combine this customized equipment with the older equipment, used on other production lines.
Given these issues, management decided to act. Seeking to grow market share and to continue to build its long-term customer base, the company contracted with C.M.T.C. to prepare for the formation of a cross-functional (e.g., Production, Purchasing, Accounting, Engineering, etc.) team of 5-6 people. This team, to be selected from the group of 20 training participants, would lead continuous improvement efforts at this company. More particularly, the team would use Lean Manufacturing technology to identify and resolve issues associated with one particular product line. This core team would, in turn, guide the formation of other teams from the shop floor, whose representatives were participating in this training.
Successful implementation of Lean Manufacturing depends on building effective work teams. My role in this process was to design and conduct a series of six, four-hour team-building workshops, over a three-week period, that would lay the groundwork for subsequent Kaizen events. Following my work, a bi-lingual Kaizen consultant from the C.M.T.C. would follow-up with sixteen hours of intensive training in Lean Manufacturing. At the conclusion of the six-week training, the client would begin working together in using newly acquired skills to identify and resolve issues for continuous improvement.
THE AUDIENCE
The outstanding characteristic of this training group was its cultural and linguistic diversity. Of the twenty participants, only four were native English-speakers. All other participants were native Spanish-speakers, from Mexican ancestry. The plant Manager and two other Supervisors, who are of Mexican decent, speak and read English fluently. The remaining 12-13 Spanish-speaking participants were uncomfortable with both written and oral English. An estimated 20% of these Spanish-speakers experienced difficulty in reading and writing Spanish.
There were also important differences in cultural values and assumptions that were reflected in the training design, and training materials. These related to such issues as: how time at work should be used, how power and authority should be exercised, how day-to-day relationships between peers should be carried out, the appropriate exercise of discipline, perceptions about the formal and informal reward systems, how much participation in decision-making and problem-solving is appropriate and desirable for hourly employees, etc.
For example, many hourly wage-roll participants in these team-building meetings openly expressed reluctance to “intrude” on the decision-making responsibilities of their bosses a common feature of work relationships in Latin American cultures. To become involved in decision-making and problem solving is perceived as a management role, and sharing power and authority was commonly seen by most participants as a sign of weakness, and undesirable. The openness and trust that productive work teams require was frustrated by a Latin cultural perspective that emphasizes the solitary nature of the human being, and his or her essential and necessary isolation from non-family members. For a definitive discussion on this point, the reader may wish to consult the work of the Mexican author, Octavo Paz, in his seminal work, The Labyrinth of Solitude (1).
LESSONS LEARNED
Training design and materials needed to reflect these data. Therefore, the training design and presentation of the material emphasized these points:
1.Build trust. In Spanish, the word “‘confianza’” is loosely translated as “trust.” Velásquez’ New Revised Spanish-English Dictionary (1974) also translates this word as “honest boldness, ” “assurance,” “firmness of opinion,” as well as describing a relationship that permits a certain secretiveness and privacy. As is generally well known, it is normative in Latin America for “confianza” to play a large role in shaping interpersonal relationships. It is also an important mitigating factor in working and organizational relationships. This certainly extends to the training arena: if ‘confianza’ is not earned and present – both among training participants and between trainees and instructor – trainees will “shut down” and learning will dramatically suffer. The usual repertoire of training tools to elicit participation and involvement will likely fail when ‘confianza’ is not present. This is particularly relevant for interpersonal communications skills training where such concepts and skills as providing relevant feedback, active listening, and self-disclosure are not only highly valued as elements of training design and delivery, but indeed are deemed by most training practitioners as fundamental to this type of training.
Therefore, the instructor’s ability to gain and maintain ‘confianza’ with the group is critical, and he or she should avoid behaviors that participants may interpret as confrontational. In virtually all Hispanic cultures, interpersonal confrontation is considered negative and potentially destructive – it is likely to be viewed as a personal challenge and an exercise of power and dominance. It does not have an “up” side, and is not valued for its own sake. U.S trainers, however, are much more accepting of confrontation, who see it as tool that can be brought to bear to resolve conflicts and differences.
Among the most effective ways to bridge the gap between these two worldviews is to consistently “model” trust-building behaviors during training, and to avoid situations, at least in the beginning, that participants consider confrontational. This often means that training is at a “slower” pace than it would be with non-Hispanic audiences – in other words, it takes a little longer to accomplish training goals. This author’s experience is that a typical “soft” skills training program is lengthened by a factor of about 20% because of these factors.
2.Stress basic skills. The training design provided many opportunities to practice new skills (e.g., active listening, conflict-resolution, problem solving in teams, decision-making approaches, etc.). Where in another training situation I might give two to three practice opportunities to learn a concept or skill, here I used anywhere from five to six or even seven opportunities to teach active listening skills, for example.
3.Minimize reading and writing. While each participant was provided a workbook of materials relevant to each training module (i.e., managing change in the workplace; interpersonal communications skills; team-building; and problem-solving in teams), it became apparent on the first day of training that most participants were struggling to understand workbook materials. Therefore, written materials and exercises were subsequently used only to reinforce concepts, case studies, role-plays and other exercises that could be verbally presented, demonstrated, and practiced.
4.Formalize Discussion. Hispanic cultures generally value politeness and formality in interpersonal relations, compared to North Americans. These values permeate virtually all facets of daily life. For example, whereas North Americans tend to generally appreciate frankness and openness in interpersonal relationships, it is safe to say this is not generally the case with Spanish-speakers who view directness as potentially confrontational and disrespectful. Therefore, training presentations, role-plays, simulations, group discussions and all the other tools available to the trainer should reflect and demonstrate these differences in cultural views. This is probably best accomplished by: (1) verbally acknowledging these differences, with the training audience; (2) making clear to participants the training objectives of the course, and what particular challenges may be posed by training.
5.Aim for clarity. The circumstances outlined above reinforce the importance and utility of being unambiguous and clear in giving directions, setting-up classroom practice opportunities, asking for participation in exercises, etc. I found that this audience required that the objectives and methods for each exercise, each small group discussion, each training intervention be discussed beforehand, and in more depth than otherwise might be required with a group of monolingual English-speaking participants.
6.Teach a common “vocabulary.” Participants had no shared sets of effective interpersonal skills that they could apply to working together. Cultural and language differences exacerbated this situation. Orders, requests, memoranda, and indeed virtually all other communications from management first had to be interpreted from English to Spanish and “filtered” down to the non-English-speaking employees on the shop floor, through bilingual supervisors and lead personnel. Inevitably, communication effectiveness suffered. This interpreting of data and communications resulted in loss of efficiencies and effectiveness that, in a monolingual work environment, would likely not have occurred.
7.Practice-practice-practice. Use many real-life examples to make a point and teach a skill. While using examples to train is recommended for virtually any training situation, in this circumstance it was advisable to minimize the use of analogies or examples that participants would probably consider to be too abstract; that is, the examples used were all from manufacturing and production, and were situations involving production Leads and Supervisors.
8.Reward performance immediately. It was particularly important to be on the lookout for and immediately reward participants who made honest efforts to learn. Because most participants were unsure of and naïve to this training material, any trainee performance that approximated or that accurately reproduced the desired behavior (e.g., effective listening) was promptly rewarded by verbal prompts and specific expressions of approval. For example, when John, a Foreman, accurately demonstrated active listening with others in the group, I said to the group, “John, you really summarized Joe’s point very well. That’s a great example of using active listening;” or, “Did anyone notice how Justin used ‘clarification’ to better understand what Juan was saying? Justin, can you repeat exactly how you used the clarification technique with Juan just now?”
9.Mix it up. Depending on audience readiness, mood, level of interest, and expressed desires, I used both Spanish and English interchangeably during training sessions. For example, I wrote key points on the flipchart in English, and summarized them in Spanish; or, I conducted one role-play in English, and another in Spanish. Other techniques were to:
produce key workbook materials and job aids in both languages. Encourage bilingual participants to summarize key points for their monolingual colleagues, and;
10. Invite trainees to participate in either English or Spanish, with the proviso that either they, a colleague, or I would immediately translate the substance of their remarks to others.
RESULTS FROM TRAINING
Was training successful? Impacts of this program should be measured after implementation of the total package including the Kaizen interventions. At that point, it will be possible to indirectly evaluate the extent to which these training sessions resulted in application of these skills to shop floor situations. Why only indirectly evaluate impacts? Because, to draw causal relationships between this training and improved workplace behaviors, the effects and influence of the Kaizen events would have to be eliminated, or considered. Given the present state of evaluation technology this does not seem possible now.
Written evaluations of each session asked to what degree trainees learned new skills. On average, eighty percent of trainees responded that they had acquired the targeted skills and knowledge in that training session. The training group, the Kaizen instructor and C.M.T.C. independently agree that this first effort has given the necessary impetus forward for Kaizen to begin and to be successful.
REFERENCES
1.López Aqueres, Waldo, Ph.D., “Business Traits, Market Characteristics, and Employment Patterns of Large Latino-Owned Firms in Southern California.” 1999: Tomás Riv4era Policy Institute: Claremont, CA
2.Macmillan Visual Almanac (1986). Woodbridge, CT: Blackbirch Press
3.Paz, Octavio (1961). The Labyrinth of Solitude. New York: Grove/Atlantic Press.
4.Riverside, Press-Enterprise, October 21, 1999.
5.U.S. Bureau of the Census. 1999. Population Estimates Program, Population Division. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
IV.AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Anthony C. Griffin holds a Master’s Degree in Adult Education and has worked as a Training Manager and Director of Training for the international operations of Ray-O-Vac Batteries, Hospital Corporation of America, Technoserve, Inc., and ITT Industries. Since 1994, he has headed his own consulting firm, Teamworks, in Riverside, California. He is a member of the American Society for Training and Development, the Association of Professional Consultants, and the International Association of Facilitators. Phone: 951-784-9330. Fax: (951) 784-5003 Email: training@teamworks1.com. Web site: www.teamworks1.com.
Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/organizational-articles/team-building-71238.html”
(ArticlesBase SC #71238)
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!
Anthony C. Griffin -
About the Author:
]]>
Questions and Answers
Ask our experts your Organizational related questions here…
200 Characters left
How do you think the project management team should make its strategic plan to overcome aforesaid challenges?
My AGM has asked to me sit with my team and work as they do. I have a target as well and my name is inculded in the team ranking as well. I’m an Asst Manager and this is not what i wanted..help
I m doing MBA 2 nd year after my B.E(ECE)…and I have 2 years of experience in sales as a team leader…still how many years it will take to become a marketing manager..and pre-requisities
Rate this Article
vote(s)
1 vote(s)
Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish
Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/organizational-articles/team-building-71238.html
Article Tags:
teams, teambuilding, spanish, automotive, management, trucks
Latest Organizational Articles
More from Anthony C. Griffin
How to Coach Team Races and Relays
Coach Joe Dinoffer talks about the value of team races and relays games in tennis training. (01:20)
This week I review the Easton Training Stick. I really do like this training aid, and I used it with my teams.
(05:24)
How to Successfully Train Sales Representatives
Find out how to create a successful selling process so that whole team can be successful sales representatives. (04:07)
This is a unique drill that uses a prop and two teams. (00:38)
How To Play Basketball: Team Rebounding Drills
Watch and learn from defensive and offensive training drills for rebound situations. (05:41)
Catering Food Storage – Organise Stock For Rotation, Food Regs and Less Wastage
Food storage is probably one of the most important organisational tasks in the catering kitchen. Plastic food containers used wisely can help in organising food storage for effective rotation and less wastage. Obviously food regs have to be met with strict adherence so food storage containers are essential kitchenware utensils. Kitchen storage may consist of tupperware style food storage or plastic storage boxes like ingredient bins. Buy all types of food storage at http://www.caterfor.co.uk
By:
Jane Lloydl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 25, 2011
Everything you wanted to know about flats storage – and more!
Considering flats storage? You have reached the right place. Here you will receive explanations and comprehensive information about the best, most efficient and most worthwhile way for flats storage. From the stage of collecting data to receiving the key to your private cell/cabin/locker.
By:
Nirl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 24, 2011
Booking Meeting Rooms with Meeting Room Software
Booking a meeting is critically important to a successful meeting, and should be done at least a week prior to the meeting date. A lot of companies have their own intranet-based software application for booking meeting rooms. These are typically self-service based applications where the user can log in and view all the available meeting rooms in the premises. Once the person finds a meeting room that meets all the requirements, he/she will book the room using that application. Now the status of
By:
Claire Jarrettl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 24, 2011
Helpful Business Application – Apply Federal Grant
Helpful Business Application – Apply Federal Grant. For anybody ropes the power world demanding to get done an spire on the competition, you reckon on gain that you need to think face the box. and you deem to utilize equipment again networks that most folks do not rolled know about.
By:
Miral
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 24, 2011
Stamp Duty Implications Arising Out Of an Issuance and Transfer of Debentures of an Unlisted Company
As part of any transaction involving issuance of debentures by a company, or transfer of debentures of a company, a crucial question which often arises is as to determination of the stamp duty payable on such issuance or transfer of debentures. The answer to this question ultimately turns upon the nature of company – whether private or public (listed or unlisted).
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 22, 2011
An internationally known specialty hospital and Cancer Research Center receives patients and conducts cancer clinical trials over a wide geographical area. To conduct trials it relies on patient referrals from specialized physicians over a broad geographical area.
By:
Chad Kopcakl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 21, 2011
Ways to Keep Check on Frequent AC Repair
Here are some common problems which should be fixed by the unit’s owners in order to keep their system effective and helps in running at top efficiency.
By:
simranfortl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 20, 2011
The Professionals’ Advice – Improving Print Management and Reducing Printing Costs
Below, we offer-up three more considered suggestions as to how any organisation can go about improving its print management and reducing its printing costs.
By:
Clive Gilbertl
Business>
Organizationall
Jan 19, 2011
When Successful Training Fails, and What to Do About It
This article discusses how classroom training can be evaluated by participants as being successful, while failing to demonstrate actual learning of new skills
By:
Anthony C. Griffinl
Business>
Organizationall
Nov 08, 2006
lViews: 2,300
lComments: 2
This is a case study of a training project conducted by the author for the client, a major truck body manufacturer. Unique to this project were the cultural characteristics of the training audience. The training was conducted in Spanish and English.
By:
Anthony C. Griffinl
Business>
Organizationall
Nov 08, 2006
lViews: 900
Add new Comment
Your Name: *
Your Email:
Comment Body: *
Verification code:*
* Required fields
Submit
Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today
Author Navigation
My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder
My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box
Anthony C. Griffin has 2 articles online
Articles Categories
All Categories
Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing
Agriculture
Ask an Expert
Business Ideas
Business Opportunities
Corporate
Customer Service
Entrepreneurship
Ethics
Franchise
Fundraising
Home Business
Human Resources
Industrial
International Business
Leadership
Management
Negotiation
Networking
Non Profit Organizations
Online Business
Organizational
Outsourcing
Presentation
Project Management
Public Company
Public Relations
Sales
Six Sigma
Small Business
Strategic Planning
Team Building
Training
]]>
Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog
Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Mobile Version
Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us
Business Info
Advertising
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.
